Yep, this part sucks. I am staying home all weekend, as I have two papers due this week, and a test, not to mention other projects due soon and two exams coming up in two weeks. But let's be honest, I have nothing else to do either.
I'm writing a paper for my Language and Gender class about various advice columns about communication between men and women in the workplace. Advice on this issue generally treats men and women as if they are different species -- you know, the Mars and Venus thing. They treat "men" and "women" as homogenous units, as groups that always do and think the same thing. Women are always talking about feelings and gossiping about people and reacting emotionally; men are always talking about facts and cutting straight to the point and reacting logically. Right. These writers have clearly not met Sanda and I -- we are cold and heartless! I think it's funny that John Grey, of
Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus fame, goes on and on about how men don't focus on relationship stuff, but he's the author of scores of books ON RELATIONSHIPS. Perhaps he is not aware that he is a man? Let's not even get into the issue of his Ph.D., which came from
a fake university.
The thing is, I know that these are over-generalizations and that we can never say that all men do something, or all women do something, or all white people do something, or all Muslims, or all rural Canadians, or any group like that. However, these ideas are very tempting, and they seem to have
some truth to them. It is true that I talk to my friends about everything, that my best friends are the friends who know all the little details, and it's true that sometimes our significant others have a problem with this because that's not how they do friendship. It's true that when we have a girls night, we'll often try to do something like go to a bookstore or something, but we end up abandoning the plan and going to a coffee shop because we want to TALK. We don't want to do stuff together and not talk, because then we feel like we didn't really hang out. We didn't catch up on the little stuff, and that's really important to girls -- at least, the ones that I'm closest with. I do know a few girls who don't seem to get this, who offer me advice when I just want empathy, who respond to me talking about frustrating situations with "I can't solve that for you" instead of saying "Wow, that really sucks." But they're generally the exception among girls, and I've come to expect that behaviour from the boys.
I remember discussions about this with Chris, where he would stop me and say, "Okay, so what's the point of this story?" and the point was: this is what my day was like, these are the things that are going on in my life, and that's it. I had a friend in Kitchener who would NEVER mention any of his friends, and it drove me crazy, because how am I supposed to know if I matter to you if you don't tell me about your life and your friends never hear about me?
And no, it's not like all the boys are like this. I do have male friends who are up for the three-hour phone conversations that ramble into random topics, but they seem to be the exception. I don't know, do they seem like the exception because we're constantly told that boys don't do that? Because THEY're constantly told that? But the answer can't be that they do this because they're men, or we do this because we're women. Penises and vaginas don't have anything to do with communicative strategies. Maybe it does have to do with femininity and masculinity (gender, not sex/anatomy), or with presenting ourselves as straight or gay, or as middle-class or lower-class, or white or ... ethnic? (Is that the new word for "people who are not like us because their skin is a little bit different"?)
I'm sure my prof would love it if I just ignored these differences and pretended that everyone was the same, but I do run into these differences. Sometimes people have different communicative strategies based on their geographic location. I've been reading about a feature of Australian English that sounds like uptalk but doesn't mean quite the same thing, it's more asking for an affirmative or negative. Maybe Caleb can chime in on that one. Sometimes it's due to group-identification, like lower-class African Americans in NYC who will say "she been here" where I would say "she's always here." These things lead to a lot of miscommunication.
I can see the motivation to deny that there's a difference between male talk and female talk in our culture, because these differences are often used to assert that we're totally different and will never be able to communicate and so we should just stop trying, or to say that women can't climb the corporate ladder because we make communication "mistakes," or to re-assert this idea that women run on hormones and couldn't make a logical statement to save our lives. I see that. But I also see variation and a reason to be educated on differences we might encounter in our various male-female relationships, whether that's at work or at home or whatever.
I just don't want to exchange "men and women are totally different" for "men and women are totally the same."