This article in the Toronto Star,
Holistic spa under scrutiny, had me both furious and hopeful at the same time.
Basically, this is the problem: There is prostitution. There is prostitution everywhere. There is prostitution even in (gasp!) Toronto and it ain't going away. Now, being that prostitution is illegal, prostitutes are not the safest people in the world. Being a hooker on the street is probably one of the most dangerous professions in the city, so, smart people that they are, they band together and run an establishment where, if something goes wrong, they have other people there to help them out. This avoids the whole "getting in the car with strangers who sometimes kill you" aspect of the job.
Much of the time, these establishments pose as holistic spas, massage parlours, etc. Because this is illegal, city inspectors spend a great deal of time in these establishments, trying to shut them down. The article states that "it's a problem that costs taxpayers $2.5 million a year in inspection and legal action costs." So, we're spending a ton of money shutting these places down. They also complain that the manager of the establishment featured in the article lied to them, saying that there was no sex happening in her establishment, when sex was happening there while she was saying it.
Well. I'm shocked. You mean, she's running an illegal business and didn't straight-out tell you? It's a shame, because drug dealers are usually so honest with the cops, why wouldn't these guys be?
"I saw a naked man on top of a naked woman on her back and he was having sex," said Peter Milczyn (Ward 5, Etobicoke-Lakeshore), who was present for the inspection Monday evening. "He was thrusting."
This is, indeed, shocking. Adults! Having consensual sex! Behind closed doors! We must stop this at once! Well, we must stop it so long as it is not a business transaction. Stripping, that's fine. Escorts, they're fine so long as you're paying for companionship and not the sex that often results. As George Carlin says, "Fucking's legal. Selling's legal. So why isn't selling fucking legal??!"
Milczyn goes on to impress me with this statement: "My personal attitude is we should be licensing brothels in a few select industrial areas with proper health monitoring — make sure it's safe and let the government collect taxes from it. We should accept reality and regulate it."
This is exactly what we should do. Instead of spending 2.5 million dollars annually on shutting these places down, we should legislate them, tax them, ensure that sex workers are tested regularly, and protect them from abuse. In New Zealand last week,
a man was fined for removing a condom while having sex with a prostitute and thus putting her life in danger. I fully support the decision, because the 'morality' of someone's job shouldn't mean that we are allowed to risk that person's health.
That, of course, will be the opposition. The 'morality' of it. Well, it doesn't really enter into it, does it? There are plenty of 'immoral' sex-related activities that are perfectly legal. The two people caught in the article would have been in the clear if there was no money exchanged -- the state doesn't legislate THAT morality. I suppose people are going to argue that if we have a red light district, suddenly EVERYONE will be using hookers. Um, except that it's already a booming industry and if you want to, you pay for sex in tons of places in Toronto. There's a girl that hangs out around Chris's building that, I'm sure, will be happy for another customer. (I'll warn you though, she's got a crazy look in her eye and makes us nervous.)
No one is going to be forced to use these services, just like no one is forced into a same-sex marriage, just because it is legal. No one is forced to drink alcohol. No one is forced to smoke. No one is forced to listen to country music. It's all good.
Personally, I would love it if we had a red-light district so that sex workers were safe, customers had a guarantee that they were disease-free, and legal recourse could be sought if people are jerks like the Kiwi mentioned above. In fact, I would go farther than that: we should offer advanced sex education for sex workers -- techniques, muscle control, interesting positions, fitness, flexibility -- and offer the world the best sex it's ever had. Toronto: Better Orgasms! It could be our new marketing strategy! Hell, it's better than the stupid
Toronto Unlimited campaign.